News & Events - Archived News

[ Up ]
 

Government may pay farmers to plow under beets

By Jeff Zent, The Forum
July 27, 2000
 

The government may soon reimburse the Red River Valley's sugar beet farmers to plow under some of this year's crop.

The U.S. Department of Agriculture is considering a payment-in-kind program to help shore up the nation's faltering sugar industry and ease the threat of massive loan forfeitures.

Under the program, sugar beet and cane farmers would pledge to destroy a portion of this year's crop. In return, the U.S. Department of Agriculture would issue certificates for government-owned sugar that farmers could exchange for cash.

In the Red River Valley, American Crystal Sugar and Minn-Dak Farmers Cooperative would pay their farmer members cash for the certificates. The cooperatives would then turn the certificates in to the government and take ownership of surplus sugar.

Jim Horvath, president and chief executive officer of American Crystal Sugar in Moorhead, testified before the Senate Agriculture Committee Wednesday and asked that a payment-in-kind program be implemented.

The Agriculture Department is "strongly considering" the proposal, but no details have been worked out, said Parks Shakelford, associate administrator for programs in the department's Farm Service Agency.

By law, farmers could not collect more than $20,000 in the program.

A payment-in-kind program could be implemented by Agriculture Secretary Dan Glickman without congressional action, said Sen. Kent Conrad of North Dakota, a senior Democrat on the Senate Agriculture Committee.

Still, that committee debated the proposal Wednesday. Committee chairman Sen. Richard Lugar, R-Ind, opposed the idea, Conrad said.

The proposal could be a huge boost to the valley's beet growers.

Sugar beet production adds about $2 billion annually to the region's economy, Conrad said.

"I guess this is just about the best idea I've heard so far," said Bill Hejl, a sugar beet farmer who lives near Amenia, N.D.

"It gives us a little breathing room while they work on what we need to do in the long term," he said.

With sugar prices at an 18-year-low, growers are threatening to forfeit up to $500 million in government loans for which the natural sweetener was used as collateral.

American Crystal has 201,000 tons of sugar on loan and Minn-Dak received federal loans on 18,000 tons.

Growing domestic production and increased imports have driven the per-pound price of refined sugar down to about 2 cents below the loan rate.

In June, the government bought 132,000 tons of surplus sugar, but the purchase did not faze low market prices.

A payment-in-kind program is the best way to eliminate surplus sugar, protect the government from costly forfeitures and help raise the price, said Mark Weber, executive director of the Red River Valley Sugarbeet Growers Association.

Taking ownership of forfeited sugar would cost the government more, Weber said.

"Forfeitures are just around the corner if something doesn't happen," Weber said. "It's something that we think can work and is a very good short-term solution."

Storage costs alone would cost the government "tens of millions of dollars", Conrad said.

"I strongly support this approach," Conrad said of the payment-in-kind proposal.

"I think what we were working on today would go a long way toward coping with the crises that currently exists."