News & Events - Archived News

[ Up ]
 

Half of California's sugar beet farmers sinking under glut of sweetener

By Kiley Russell, Associated Press Writer
October 3, 2000
 
TRACY, Calif. (AP) -- California's sugar beet farmers, who once produced a year-round supply for nine refineries scattered from the Imperial Valley to the Oregon border, are looking for other crops to plant as two of California's four remaining sugar processing plants plan to close this winter.

Disastrously low sugar prices and the rising cost of California land have just about killed off the 120-year-old industry.

The two latest to fail are the Spreckles plants in Woodland and Tracy, areas whose proximity to San Francisco and Sacramento have made them prime targets for suburban development. The land rush has driven prices to record levels.

"Oh, man, it's horrible. It really has implications all over the dadgum state," said Ben Goodwin, manager of the California Beet Growers Association.

"When these two plants close, there's no other place to go. The two remaining plants will have all the beets they need," Goodwin said.

The factories, owned by Imperial Sugar Inc. of Sugar Land, Texas, are closing because the land value is greater than the earning value of plants. The closures will put about 580 permanent and seasonal employees out of work.

"Those factories have relatively high operating costs and so they couldn't support themselves. In addition, the land is very valuable, so the focus was to free it up for sale," Imperial Sugar Vice President Bill Schwer said.

The company offered to sell the refineries to California's sugar beet farmers in February, but so far a committee of growers have not been able to figure out a way make the operations profitable, Goodwin said. If the farmers can't come up with a way to buy the plants and keep them open, Schwer said they will stop processing sugar beets by the end of the 2000 season.

Neither Schwer nor Goodwin would say how much the company is asking for the properties.

California's 500 beet farmers, working about 115,000 acres, accounted for about 8 percent of the roughly 5 million tons of beet sugar produced in the United States last year. California's crop is expected set production records with 34 tons of sugar beets coming off every acre. That's 2 tons higher than ever before, Goodwin said.

But overproduction nationwide has been driving prices down for much of the 1990s. Since 1995 prices have dropped about 30 percent to $22 per 100 pounds of refined sugar. A fourth of that decline has hit since December 1999.

The U.S. Department of Agriculture estimates that the wholesale price for beet and cane sugar has dropped to an 18-year low. The soft sugar market is putting pressure on farmers and processors all over the country.

"I've seen the market go up and down, of course, but I've never seen it this depressed," said Neil Hamilton, who grows sugar beets, wheat and other crops on about 2,000 acres in the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta.

In September, 300 workers lost their jobs when the U.S. Sugar Corp. plant in Clewiston, Fla., began a cost-cutting program. The announcement came a week after two of the state's biggest growers forfeited $17 million in sugar to repay government loans.

In the Rocky Mountain states, growers are trying to come up with the money to buy Tate & Lyle's six sugar factories in Colorado, Nebraska, Montana and Wyoming. The company announced in May that the depressed sugar market is driving it out of its operations in those states.

In Hawaii, Amfac/JMB Hawaii Inc. plans to close its two mills on Kauai, lay off 400 workers and sell more than 17,000 acres of land. Also, Alexander & Baldwin Inc. plans to close its sugar plant on Maui.

In an effort to reduce the national oversupply and hopefully increase the price a bit, the USDA announced a program in late August to pay farmers up to $20,000 each to destroy part of their sugar beet crop this year.

About 3,100 acres in California are registered under the program so far.