News & Events - Archived News

[ Up ]
 

U.S. - Mexico sugar dispute continues

By Andrea Mandel-Campbell in Mexico City
October 24, 2000
 
Mexico could take retaliatory measures against the US if it continues to waver over Mexico's allotted sugar quotas, a high-ranking trade official warned on Monday.

Last month, the US allotted Mexico a sugar quota of 116,000 tonnes beginning Oct 1, but the US has yet to supply Mexico with a schedule of shipping patterns necessary to complete the shipments, said Luis de la Calle, Mexico's deputy trade minister.

Mexico is the only country exporting sugar to the US not to have been provided with shipping patterns, said Mr de la Calle. He warned that Mexico could respond by delaying the allotment of quotas on agricultural products imported from the US.

"Playing with shipping patterns is not wise," he said. "We also have quotas for US imports."

The delay comes as Mexico and the US prepare to go to a dispute settlement panel over sugar exports. Mexico called for an arbitration panel to be set up under the North American Free Trade Agreement (Nafta) in August after the US refused to up its imports of Mexican sugar from 25,000 to some 550,000 tonnes.

The two countries are disputing the interpretation of the opening of the sugar industry agreements set under Nafta. According to the Mexicans, they should be able to export their entire sugar surplus, estimated at some 550,000 tonnes, as of Oct 1, 2000.

The US points to a side agreement signed by the trade ministers of both countries which takes into account Mexican consumption of high fructose corn syrup, a cheaper sugar substitute, in calculating its surplus. Using that calculation, Mexico's surplus is 116,000 tonnes.

Mexico argues however, that the side agreement was not ratified by its Congress and is therefore not valid.

Mr De la Calle did not, however, discount reaching a settlement with the US over the sugar dispute before the panel made a decision. He said Mexico had already modified its position by seeking to reach a temporary two to three year agreement instead of an original eight-year deal. Under Nafta all barriers to sugar exports end in 2008.