News & Events - Archived News

[ Up ]
 
Politicos missing chance for sweet deal
Gazette Opinion, The Billings Gazette
January 8, 2001
 
Republicans and Democrats awaited their turns at the podium this fall to explain how they would turn this state's economy around, drag us back from the bottomless pit.

But now a crisis has arisen - and an opportunity - and these politicians are as silent as a December snowfall.

Montana sugar-beet farmers face the possible closure of the Western Sugar plant in Billings. That would endanger the economic well being of 1,100 farmers growing 193,000 acres of sugar beets this year.

Al Jones, a regional development officer for the Economic Development Division of the Montana Department of Commerce, said, "There's a domino effect of damaging the malting barley business as well as the cattle market which could have a crippling effect in this area which could really hurt agriculture. For a fair number of growers, that could mean losing the farm."

Jobs at stake 

As agriculture goes in Montana, so goes the economy. At stake in Billings is the possible loss of 600 jobs and a $50 million hole poked in the city's economy.

Sugar beet growers in Montana, Wyoming, Colorado and Nebraska are trying to buy Tate & Lyle LLC's Western Sugar Co.'s six refineries. Tate & Lyle seems amenable to the plan. The company promised employees that it wouldn't leave them high and dry.

But a glut of sugar on the world market and collapsing prices forced the British firm to make hard decisions. 

More help needed 

Beet growers have begun assessing themselves $35 an acre to help fund the purchase. More money is needed.

The only thing lacking in the process has been an effort by state officials to smooth the way for the sale. All those politicians who promised to help fix the state economy are standing by with their hands in their pockets while this crisis/opportunity slips past unnoticed.

A couple of points might be considered here. 

Some points to consider 

First, establishing ethanol plants in Montana may be a wave of the future in renewable energy sources. That will require large amounts of sugar. Local ownership of sugar plants seems to fit into that picture. A united effort to boost the profit from two sectors of Montana's agricultural economy is certainly in the state's best interest.

Second, rather than spending all their time courting new businesses for Montana - a Gazette employee recently commented that the effort is analogous with going door-to-door to sell a car - we should be doing everything we can to improve the strength and longevity of existing businesses, especially those relating to agriculture.

Third, it's time all the promises from the last election are twisted into reality. Public agencies should be doing what they can to make this purchase possible. It's tough to catch that brass ring if you have your hands in your pockets.