WASHINGTON -- A bipartisan group of lawmakers Wednesday
called for an end to the federal sugar program, saying it
amounts to corporate welfare, inflates the price of food,
pollutes the environment and costs jobs.
The bill by Rep. Dan Miller, a Republican from Bradenton,
and Rep. George Miller, D-Calif., would phase down the federal
loan rate for sugar to 14 cents a pound from 18 cents, require
the loans to be repaid in cash -- not crops, as the current
program allows -- and eliminate import restrictions on foreign
sugar.
The federal sugar program "is one of the most
egregious forms of corporate welfare we have in this
country," Dan Miller, a longtime opponent of the sugar
program, said at a Capitol Hill news conference.
George Miller said, "It's become very, very clear over
this last crop year that the federal sugar program is
completely dysfunctional, it's completely broken and it's
failing on all fronts."
In the budget year that ended Sept. 30, sugar processors
forfeited nearly 892,500 tons of raw sugar at a cost to the
federal government of $465 million. The government also is
paying about $1.4 million a month to the sugar processors to
warehouse the raw sugar.
South Florida's three sugar companies -- U.S. Sugar Corp.
in Clewiston, Palm Beach-based Florida Crystals and the Sugar
Cane Growers Cooperative of Florida in Belle Glade, forfeited
a total of 294,000 tons of sugar, worth about $100 million,
last fall.
News of the lawmakers' move raised hackles Wednesday at
U.S. Sugar.
"It's outrageous that American congressional
representatives want to give America's sugar market to
subsidize foreign producers," said Judy Sanchez, U.S.
Sugar's spokeswoman. "They're being pushed by the big
candy and food companies, who want to increase their profit
margins at the expense of the American farmers. They're the
driving force behind this."
The congressmen cited a recent General Accounting Office
study that estimated the sugar program costs the American
consumer $1.9 billion a year in higher food prices.
The lawmakers also said the sugar program has contributed
to the pollution of the Everglades by encouraging growing on
marginally productive land.
Under the proposed bill, the loan price for sugar would
decline by a penny a pound until it reached 14 cents in budget
year 2004. It would remain at that level indefinitely.
Meanwhile, import restrictions on foreign sugar -- designed
to keep domestic sugar prices above the 18-cent loan rate --
also would be phased out until the U.S. sugar price was either
the rate at which sugar is sold on the world market or at the
loan rate plus interest.
Staff writer Susan Salisbury contributed to this story. |