PAUL -- Initial tests show that Oust -- an herbicide made by
DuPont and applied by the Bureau of Land Management on 17,000
acres scorched by wildfire last August -- is responsible for
damage to crops within a one-quarter mile radius of the
treated BLM land.
Affected sugar beet acreage is more than double the area
that was sprayed after the fire, with the tally now about
38,000 acres -- well up from the 10,000-acre estimate of last
week.
"This is the first set of results we have received
from samples taken last week," said Bob Spencer,
agrochemical specialist with the Idaho State Department of
Agriculture. "We will expand the soil sampling to a
radius of 1 to 5 miles and beyond if necessary."
The result, obtained from tests conducted by Montana State
University, indicate a range of levels of Oust in the soils
from 0.079 parts per billion (ppb) to 24 ppb, while the lowest
level that can be detected is 0.05 ppb. The samples were taken
from areas that appear to have the most severe damage and
subject to drought-induced soil erosion, according to the ISDA.
The announcement by the Department of Agriculture confirmed
what a group of farmers had surmised, said Dan Schaeffer of
Hazleton, spokesman for the group of farmers whose crops have
been damaged.
Crops are showing anywhere from dead to moderate damage, he
said, and that will take a toll on yields.
John Schorr, Amalgamated Sugar Company's ag manager at the
Paul factory, said it's too early to tell exactly how much
tonnage will be lost
"We haven't put a number to it," he said. But
"every time we don't get a beet processed we don't have
sugar to sell."
Tonnage loss out of the field is not the only
consideration. Use of the affected sugar beets in processing
is also something to think about.
"We have been told that in the process of producing
sugar there is no chance of it carrying over into the food
chain," said John Schorr, Amalgamated Sugar Company's ag
manager at the Paul factory.
But if some of the crop is partially contaminated it may
mean destroying it, he said, adding that farmers want to do
everything possible to ensure food safety from the crops they
produce.
"Idaho is known for safe crops," Schorr said.
"We want to maintain that."
Compensation for damages is another issue that will no
doubt take precedence as the season unfolds.
About 17,000 of the affected sugar beet acres are in the
Aberdeen-American Falls area and the rest is in Minidoka
County and east Jerome County, Schaeffer said. In addition,
some corn and grain fields were also damaged. Farmers will
know later if potatoes were damaged. Hay does not appear to be
damaged because roots are deep.
Some of the Aberdeen-American Falls damage appears to have
originated from Minidoka County dust storms, he said, adding
that drought conditions are to blame for the loose dirt that
is spreading the herbicide. With no vegetation or moisture to
hold it in place, the soil was more subject to erosion this
winter than in the past.
Leonard Kerbs, Amalgamated's ag manager for the Twin Falls
District, said this has been one of the windiest years on
record.
But wind may not be the only factor involved in crop
damage. The BLM is also gathering data as to which chemicals
farmers used and is checking a number of other factors, said
David Howell, spokesman for BLM.
While the BLM and Dupont are conducting investigations,
Amalgamated is also gathering material, Schorr said.
"Our field staff are looking at every field and
evaluating," Schorr said. "We are making sure we get
all the data."
If the damage is caused by the wind the problem would be
considered an act of God and farmers would not be held
responsible to met their contract quota, Schorr said.
One way or another, "there would be a need for
compensation from whoever caused the problem," he said.
But it is too early to tell what the outcome will be.
"It's devastating, especially in the economy we've
got," Schaeffer said.
BLM officials, Dupont personnel, and Idaho congressmen have
been attending meetings with farmers, Schaeffer said. He is
pleased that those involved are working well with the farmers.
"Everybody is talking," Howell said.
"Farmers have been great to work with."
Within a couple more weeks, testing should be completed and
BLM officials will decide if compensation is warranted, Howell
said.
"We're having that conversation," he said.
"That (a decision) will be something that comes down the
road."
BLM officials have not ruled out the possibility that
strong winds could have been responsible for spreading the
herbicide to the now affected fields.
"That is one of the things we're taking a look
at," Howell said.
In the meantime BLM has discontinued the use of Oust. |