KANSAS CITY, Mo. -- While American consumers ponder the
merits of genetically modified foods, a small but growing
number of farmers are establishing systems to keep such
foodstuffs from showing up on kitchen tables.
Those farmers are commanding higher prices for going
through the rigors of raising "identity-preserved"
crops and cattle -- farm products whose chain of custody can
be documented from beginning to end.
Months before StarLink corn was found in taco shells,
Kansas farmer Ken McCauley worried that the genetically
enhanced corn could damage the U.S. crop more than the pests
it was modified to combat.
McCauley belongs to AgraMarke Inc., a 500-member
cooperative based in northeast Kansas that is on the cutting
edge of growing identity-preserved crops.
StarLink
StarLink was the first corn approved only as an animal
feed, pending findings that its genetic tinkering would not
cause allergic reactions in people. Common sense told McCauley
it was going to be tricky to keep StarLink from getting into
groceries. The U.S. grain system largely provides humans with
the same corn fed to pigs and cattle.
"A lot of guys (who) planted (StarLink) just didn't
understand it needed to be kept separated," McCauley
says. "So it got mixed in the field and then mixed again
in the bin and again in the elevators, and it just
magnified."
When an environmental watchdog group announced in September
that traces of StarLink had been found in taco shells,
potentially putting consumers at risk, it sent shudders
through the food chain.
Food companies pulled products from grocery shelves. Grain
elevators and mills were closed for cleaning. International
sales tanked and already dismal commodity prices took another
hit.
Aventis CropScience, creator of StarLink, pulled the seed
corn off the market and is reimbursing some of these expenses
at a cost estimated at more than $1 billion.
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reported
that its tests show the protein implanted in StarLink does not
cause allergic reactions. Even so, McCauley thinks the market
for identity-preserved products will blossom.
Bold step
Only 4 years old, AgraMarke this month bought a cereal mill
that Quaker Oats was closing in St. Joseph, Mo. To AgraMarke
growers, having StarLink near their specialized corn is
anathema.
"In 1999, StarLink was around, but nobody was paying a
nickel's worth of attention," says McCauley at the mill,
which sprawls over 36 acres in south St. Joseph.
"It was a bold step to tell farmers they couldn't grow
StarLink if they wanted to join our group," says
McCauley, who was on the biotechnology advisory counsel for
AgraMarke.
U.S. agriculture has the capacity to grow, collect and move
billions of bushels of grain around the world. But it is a
system that pays farmers rock-bottom prices and blends their
crops into an average mix. The industry stumbles when it tries
to separate different types of the same grain.
If any good comes from the StarLink episode, it will be
from emphasizing the need to move farmers and millers toward
an identity-preserved system, says Fred Stemme, spokesman for
the Missouri Corn Growers Association.
"The challenges with StarLink may be helping,"
Stemme says.
Meeting specifications
AgraMarke is not alone in this arena. National Starch,
which has a plant in Kansas City, Mo., has contracted with
farmers for 35 years to grow identity-preserved corn that
meets certain specifications for their adhesives. Some beef
producers, such as U.S. Premium Beef and the American Hereford
Association, both in Kansas City, have identity-preserved
programs that allow them to get higher prices for some of
their beef by certifying they meet specific standards.
But it still is a fledgling movement. Only an estimated 4
percent of the 76 million to 80 million acres of corn grown
each year are identity preserved.
AgraMarke actually grew out of an effort about four years
ago to buy and preserve a grain elevator in Everest, Kan.,
that served farmers in northeast Kansas and northwest
Missouri. As they worked on that deal, many of the farmers
began talking about how they might prosper growing corn and
soybeans when historically low prices for those commodities
wouldn't pay farmers' fuel and fertilizer bills.
"A lot of it was inspired by $1.70 corn," says
McCauley, who raises corn and soybeans on about 3,500 acres in
Kansas. "We had to do something."
Segregating crops
For decades, the percentage of the food dollar earned by
farmers has decreased while the food processors -- the
companies turning poultry into chicken tenders and corn into
nacho chips -- have seen their share increase. In hopes of
getting more profit from their crops, new farm cooperatives
have popped up to build ethanol plants, buy taco making
facilities or invest in meat processing plants.
AgraMarke members expect to earn about 10 percent more by
growing crops that meet certain characteristics. AgraMarke
segregated 5.5 million bushels of crops last year, mostly
corn. They expect to segregate 7.5 million bushels of corn,
wheat and soybeans this year.
Currently, most of AgraMarke's customers want corn that has
not been genetically modified. But the cooperative is not
opposed to genetically modified crops. In fact, AgraMarke
expects its future to be pinned to new crops that have been
genetically modified to provide nutritional or health benefits
for humans or livestock. AgraMarke members think their system
will keep them free of the kind of problems that StarLink
caused.
"Our focus is on the consumer. What they want, we will
grow," says Bill Becker, director of marketing for
AgraMarke. "Over the past 50 years, we have been eating
the same corn that our livestock eats. We need to make sure
there are better varieties for humans, enhanced varieties for
livestock. We may as well segregate them for the use they are
intended for."
The cooperative evolved further when it recently began
selling as much as $6 million in shares to acquire the plant
in St. Joseph. The mill will allow AgraMarke to make specialty
flours and eventually other processed foods.
Chain of custody
AgraMarke members must agree to strict planting, harvesting
and storage guidelines to guarantee that their crops meet
customer specifications and are neither tainted by pollen
drifting from other fields nor mixed with unapproved
varieties. Some members only grow identity-preserved varieties
to streamline the process and protect against problems.
Planting must be planned a year in advance to make sure fields
are protected.
AgraMarke members also must submit to inspections of their
fields and equipment by independent evaluators.
Farmers planting StarLink, in contrast, signed agreements
to meet planting and storage procedures that many in the
industry think they didn't understand, forgot or chose not to
follow. There wasn't a verification process to make sure they
did.
"We don't just sign a contract and say, 'I will be a
good old boy and follow the contract,'" Becker says.
"We have a strict, third-party verification
process."
AgraMarke pays the Kansas Crop Improvement Association to
conduct inspections on the cooperative's grains. Daryl Strouts,
executive director of the association, thinks AgraMarke is on
the leading edge with its identity preservation program,
because it has pulled together into one system all of the key
elements.
"It is like a chain of custody," Strouts says.
"At any point in the process, you can determine who is
responsible and did what they were supposed to do."
The crop association verifies that AgraMarke members plant
the right seeds, that fields won't be contaminated by the
previous year's crop and that fields have buffers to prevent
crops from being affected by neighboring fields. The
association even checks the cleanliness of trucks and farm
equipment to make sure the agreed-upon crop isn't spoiled by
the remnants of another harvest -- one of the ways StarLink
could have contaminated corn stocks.
In a low-price commodity system, Strouts says, farmers and
grain buyers meet minimum standards. AgraMarke grows for a
specific customer, finding out what the customer wants and
then going back through the system to make sure its growers
provide it.
"AgraMarke is way out front, because they do some
things that are fairly unique," Strouts says. |