News & Events - Archived News

[ Up ]
 
Mexico's seizing sugar mills sign of nation's trade woes
By Susan Ferriss, Palm Beach Post-Cox News Service
September 10, 2001
 

ZACATEPEC, Mexico -- The towering smokestack and hulking exterior of Zacatepec's sugar mill was like the Hoover Dam of this town back in 1937.

That's when Mexican President Lazaro Cardenas inaugurated the once-impressive state-owned processing plant before crowds of enthralled peasant farmers.

But today the Emiliano Zapata mill of Zacatepec has become a rusted symbol of Mexico's vexing trade problems and corruption-plagued privatization endeavors of the 1990s.

The mill, which was privatized in 1992 along with many other sugar-processing plants, was one of 27 mills seized Monday by the government of President Vicente Fox. The takeover came because the plants, which process almost half the country's sugar, are suspected of fraud and owe billions of dollars to the government, cane growers and others.

The problems of Mexico's mills are linked to their inability to export their surplus production to the U.S. market, said Reg McQuaid, a researcher with B.W. Dyer & Co., brokers in sweeteners and foods based in Bernardsville, N.J. The United States and Mexico have argued over the amount of sugar Mexico is allowed to export to the U.S., and Mexico had to export its surplus onto the depressed world market at a loss.

Florida's three sugar companies, Florida Crystals Corp. in West Palm Beach, U.S. Sugar Corp. in Clewiston and the Belle Glade-based Sugar Cane Growers Cooperative of Florida, have fought any increase in Mexico's sugar quota.

Following the North American Free Trade Agreement six years ago, Mexican sugar producers geared up for a larger market share that never materialized. The industry's problems are many.

"Those who came to run this place (in the 1990s) didn't perform any maintenance. They just took advantage and pocketed money," said sugar cane grower Francisco Toledo, 73, who lives outside this town about 75 miles south of Mexico City in Morelos state.

For months farmers have been urging government intervention in this crisis, and recently have blocked highways and staged protests to provoke action.

Although Fox is a committed free market advocate, he said the government takeover, which could last 18 months, was necessary. Mexico's failing sugar industry employs, directly and indirectly, more than 600,000 people in various states.

Because of fraud, ineptitude and an inability to compete against an influx of cheaper U.S. sweeteners -- especially corn fructose -- analysts say Mexico's sugar industry has racked up an estimated $2.5 billion in debt since it was privatized 10 years ago.

Privatization of failing state-run industries -- like sugar -- was a centerpiece of the 1988-1994 government of former President Carlos Salinas de Gortari. Salinas is now widely viewed as a disgrace in Mexico because of corrupt practices that took place during his term.

Many of the companies that took over the sugar mills during Salinas' government received generous subsidies until Fox intervened this week.

Fox said the purpose of the sugar mill takeover is to "inject funds" before returning them to the private sector. The government had to act, too, because of the urgent needs of the cane producers, he said.

Fox also pledged to "insist" that the United States raise U.S. quotas on Mexican sugar imports while taking steps to ensure "that the foreign market doesn't inundate us with fructose and other sweeteners."

susanf@coxnews.com