WASHINGTON - The Senate on Wednesday effectively killed action this year
on a bill opposed by President Bush to expand federal farm subsidies
just before next years congressional elections. Democrats said they
will try again in January.
For the third time in the past three weeks, Democrats were unable to
muster the 60 votes needed to cut off debate and bring the legislation
to a final vote.
We have to move on, Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle,
D-S.D., said before the 54-43 roll call. He said he would bring the bill
back to the Senate floor when lawmakers return from their holiday recess
in late January.
The farm-bill deadlock was a victory for the Bush administration,
which had opposed the measure and urged Congress to delay the
legislation until next year. It was a defeat for the Senate Agriculture
Committee chairman, Iowa Democrat Tom Harkin, who is up for re-election
in 2002.
Harkin accused Republicans of stalling and said the stalemate puts at
risk $73.5 billion set aside for farmers in a congressional budget
agreement this year. This is really a sad day and not a bright
Christmas next week for farmers, ranchers and people who live in rural
America. What weve said to them is you dont count, he said.
Republicans denied the stalling charge. Senate Minority Leader Trent
Lott, R-Miss., said farm legislation would be a top priority of the
Senate in January. We can complete action in due time, he
said.
On Tuesday, the Senate rejected an alternative Republican farm bill,
55-40.
All the bills would increase spending on farm programs by nearly 80
percent over the next 10 years and reauthorize farm and nutrition
programs through 2006.
The Senate Democratic bill, however, would raise crop subsidies and
create a new payment program tied to changes in commodity prices. The
GOP bill rejected on Tuesday didnt increase subsidy rates but offered
farmers more money in fixed annual payments to go with matching deposits
for IRA-style savings accounts.
Democrats said the GOP measure, supported by the Bush administration,
provided an inadequate safety net for producers and too little money for
conservation.
GOP Sens. Lincoln Chafee of Rhode Island, Susan Collins of Maine,
Gordon Smith of Oregon, Olympia Snowe of Maine and Arlen Specter of
Pennsylvania voted with Democrats to defeat the Republican bill.
Defeat of the Republican alternative sends a pretty clear
signal of where the votes are and provides momentum to the
Democratic legislation, said Sen. Kent Conrad, D-N.D.
Even if the Senate were to approve a farm bill this week, Harkin
admitted theres probably no time for the House and Senate to
negotiate a final version of the legislation before Christmas.
Farm groups say Congress needs to finish work on a bill quickly,
because they fear lawmakers will be unwilling to spend as much on
agriculture programs after new budget forecasts early next year.