The Senate failed to come up with the necessary three-fifths vote to end
debate on the farm bill Wednesday, effectively killing chances of the
bill passing this year.
The 54-43 vote to limit debate to another 30 hours was the
culmination of a highly partisan battle that makes it likely Congress
will have less money to spend on farm programs when it resumes debate
next year, said Senate Agriculture Committee Chair Tom Harkin (D-IA).
"I think this is a sad day and not a very bright Christmas next
week for farmers and ranchers and people who live in rural
America," Harkin said on the floor of the Senate. "We are
going to put our farmers and ranchers in a terrible position next year,
all because of the vote that was held 15 minutes ago."
Senator Richard Lugar, the ranking Republican on the Senate
Agriculture Committee, said the additional money for agriculture that
Harkin is seeking to protect, isn't available now that the nation has
entered a recession and "hasn't been there for a long time."
"This bill was crafted to benefit a fairly small number of
farmers in America," he said, adding that most of the money would
go to just 10% of the farmers in his home state of Indiana. "What
about the other 90%?"
"I'm grateful that we have a second chance to do something
better for American farmers," Lugar said.
In a telephone press conference after the vote, Harkin said the same
bill remains on the floor of the Senate and that he'll bring it up for a
vote again when Senators return to Washington in January.
"I see no reason to rewrite the bill that came out of
committee," Harkin said.
Harkin said he thinks one reason Republicans didn't want to end
debate on the farm bill is that they wanted to attach an economic
stimulus bill to it that hadn't been agreed to by Democratic leadership
in Congress. He speculated that the administration's budget for
agriculture next year will be smaller.
Harkin said the delay is likely to make it more difficult for some
farmers to get fi nancing for next year's crops, especially for farmers
in the South who will be seeking loans in January and February.
Mary Kay Thatcher, a lobbyist for American Farm Bureau, one of 32
groups that was urging members of the Senate to pass a farm bill this
year, acknowledged that it will be difficult to save the $73.5 billion
in additional farm program spending (over 10 years) that Congress had
agreed to this year.
"What we expect is a continuing fight for ways to move the farm
bill along and to protect the $73.5 billion," she told @griculture
Online. But the Congressional Budget Office will release a new federal
budget estimate on January 24, the day after Congress returns to
Washington. That could increase resistance among urban members of
Congress to spending money on farm programs, she said.
Meanwhile, "We'll be making a concerted effort in the next month
to keep farmers informed and fired up," she said.