Curly Top is a virus disease caused by Beet Curly Top Virus (BCTV). The
virus is presumably indigenous to the Mediterranean basin, and was introduced into North
America before the start of the 20th century. As do most viruses, BCTV has a vector that
moves it from plant to plant. The beet leafhopper is the vector for BCTV in North America.
Today, BCTV occurs throughout the western United States, including the eastern slope of
the Rocky Mountains, Texas panhandle, south-western Canada and in Mexico.
2. Symptoms
The virus causes severe symptoms on sugarbeet. These symptoms develop on
young leaves after infection. No symptoms develop on leaves that mature at the time of
infection. Soon after infection by BCTV, the leaf veins become roughened on the lower side
and often produce swellings and spine-like outgrowths (see Image #1). Infected plants
develop dwarfed tap roots, and will be woody and brittle with lateral roots becoming
twisted and deformed. The malformed roots are less functional and plants may wilt during
the heat of the day (see Image #2). A clear liquid may appear in the petioles of infected
plants. This liquid will usually oxidize to a dark color. Cross sections of diseased tap
root usually exhibit dark vascular bundles that appear as concentric rings throughout the
tap root. Sections of petioles from infected plants exhibit darkened vascular bundles as
well.
Click image for full page view.
Image
#1 Image #2
Image #3
BCTV belongs to the virus group called Gemini-viruses. These viruses are
small spherical particles composed of a single strand of DNA surrounded by proteins. The
particles are very small (approximately 0.8 millionths of an inch in diameter), always
exist in pairs and can only be observed with an electron microscope. The viruses only
infect and replicate in the phloem tissue of the plant. The phloem is part of the vascular
system of the plant and its function is to move carbohydrates throughout all the plant's
tissues. A leafhopper inserts its stylet into the phloem as it feeds on a plant. Infected
leafhoppers inject virus particles into the phloem during this feeding process. The virus
particles replicate in the phloem tissue and are distributed throughout the plant in this
conducting tissue.
The beet leaf hopper (Circulifer tenellus) is one of the most
important insect pests of sugarbeets in the western United States because it is the vector
of BCTV. The beet leafhopper is small (1/8 inch long) and pale green to gray in color. The
insect over-winters on biennial and perennial plants. The winter rains bring about wild
mustard and other winter annuals that occur on uncultivated fields and range lands. The
insect spends the winter and spring as adults, feeding on these winter hosts. In the
spring, females deposit eggs on these hosts, and the first generation of leafhoppers
hatches. As the temperatures warm, and the winter annuals mature, the first generation
leafhoppers migrate out of the range lands to sugarbeet fields, carrying the virus with
them. Leafhoppers produce several generations each year, which migrate through susceptible
crops spreading the virus. As the crops mature and dry, the leafhoppers move back into the
over wintering areas in search of the winter host.
Leafhoppers are capable of long distance movement. In some areas,
leafhopppers may migrate 400 miles or more, from the winter breeding areas to cultivated
fields. Leafhoppers moving from breeding grounds in southern Arizona are known to have
carried the virus to sugarbeet crops growing near Grand Junction, Colorado. Curly Top
sporadically occurs east of the Mississippi River, indicating a very long dissemination
from western breeding grounds. Leafhoppers acquire BCTV by feeding on infected host,
either the winter host or crop plants. Leafhoppers are able to acquire the virus during
very short feeding times. The leafhopper retains the ability to transmit BCTV for a month
or more after acquisition. The vector may maintain the virus during its over-wintering
period.
5. Disease Control
Curly top is being controlled by a complex integration of various
approaches. Today, variety resistance is the backbone of curly top control. All major
companies involved in sugarbeet variety development for the West and the intermountain
region have active Curly Top resistance programs. Most varieties approved for planting in
these areas must meet or exceed Curly Top resistance standards set by local variety
evaluation committees. Sugarbeet seed companies continue to search for improved varieties
with Curly top resistance.
In addition to variety resistance, Curly Top is being controlled by
other approaches. Planting date is a very important factor in dealing with Curly Top.
Resistance in sugarbeet to damage and infection increases with plant age. Young seedlings
are very susceptible to infection and damage. Early spring planting, or in California,
fall planting, limits infection and damage due to BCTV. The early planted beets achieve
significant size before the leafhopper flights and incur less damage than smaller
seedlings.
Reduction to leafhopper breeding areas is another approach at curly top
control. In California and Wyoming, The Curly Top Virus Control Program monitors the
populations of leafhoppers and the incidence of BCTV in the over-wintering areas.
Elimination of host plants in the over-wintering areas reduces the leafhopper population.
The program uses insecticide sprays to reduce leafhopper populations before the
leafhoppers migrate to cultivated areas in the spring of the year. The California Curly
Top Virus Control Program publishes advisories and makes recommendations to growers on how
to limit the disease. Similar programs exist in other states.
The development of systemic insecticides has aided in Curly Top control.
The insecticides only affect the leafhoppers after they feed on the plants, so BCTV
infections still occur, but these chemicals limit additional spread of the vector and the
virus. In furrow treatments of Phorate are very effective for curly top control,
apparently acting as a repellent, keeping the leafhopper out of the sugarbeet fields, thus
preventing virus infection.
The Curly Top disease of sugarbeet has been a menace since the inception
of the sugarbeet industry in the western United States. A malady that at one time nearly
eliminated sugarbeet production west of the Rocky Mountains is now mostly under control
through the cooperation of growers, plant breeders and regulatory agencies. We haven't
eliminated the disease, but we have learned to live with it and to continue the successful
cultivation of sugarbeets in spite of it. Perhaps curly top control represents on of the
first and most successful applications of integrated pest management.
|